Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

CD-Copy

2 views
Skip to first unread message

Unknown

unread,
Sep 15, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/15/00
to
On Sat, 16 Sep 2000 22:14:53 +0100, "Mel C" <spe...@btinternet.com>
wrote:

>"alienboy231" <alien...@home.com> wrote
>> Oh god, well you sorry sons of bitches are absolutely useless.
>
> No, we just don't indulge in stealing in the real world as much as some
>other people.
>
> Ha-Harrrr, matey.
>
>
> TAST Spice
>

There is also the possibility that he wants to protect his purchased
copy by making a back up. I doubt that if something happens to his cd,
the software shop will gladly replace it.

alienboy231

unread,
Sep 15, 2000, 11:30:19 PM9/15/00
to
Does anyone know how I make a CD Copy of Thief 2? I have Net Nero and Clone
CD.


Chris Csernica

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
alienboy231 wrote:
>
> Does anyone know how I make a CD Copy of Thief 2? I have Net Nero and Clone
> CD.

Yes. You go down to the store and buy a second copy.

Tom Hayward

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
*cough*

alienboy231

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to

Mel C

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
"alienboy231" <alien...@home.com> wrote

> Oh god, well you sorry sons of bitches are absolutely useless.

No, we just don't indulge in stealing in the real world as much as some

duckhater

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to

"alienboy231" <alien...@home.com> wrote in message
news:dYOw5.3044$Y6.4...@news1.mntp1.il.home.com...

> Oh god, well you sorry sons of bitches are absolutely useless.
>
Sorry if some others in the group seem a little self-righteous to you,
alienboy, so I'll tell you how to make a copy of the CD just to show you
we're not all mean-hearted. Use 2 drives - put the blank one in your
CD-writer. Take your original Thief CD, and clean it with lighter fluid.
Throw a match on it, insert it in your drive, and run your duping software.
Voila! There you go. Glad I could help.

Warren

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
duckhater wrote:

> Sorry if some others in the group seem a little self-righteous to you,
> alienboy, so I'll tell you how to make a copy of the CD just to show you
> we're not all mean-hearted. Use 2 drives - put the blank one in your
> CD-writer. Take your original Thief CD, and clean it with lighter fluid.
> Throw a match on it, insert it in your drive, and run your duping software.
> Voila! There you go. Glad I could help.

NO NO NO!!! How many times do we have to post this?? It's NOT lighter fluid,
its Gasoline!! Lighter fluid will ruin your CD - too much alkaline.

You need to soak it in gasoline with an octane of 89 or higher for 3.5 minutes,
THEN place it on the 2nd CD tray, light it, and close the door.

Try to keep up, duck.

Warren

--
Online Options Web Design
http://www.onlineoptions.net/
Domain Names: $27.50/year

duckhater

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
Sorry, should've known a fuel in a heavier hydrocarbon range was needed.
Thanks for the correction and your patience, Warren.

"Warren" <war...@onlineoptions.net> wrote in message
news:39C3F5D8...@onlineoptions.net...

Warren

unread,
Sep 16, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/16/00
to
duckhater wrote:

> Sorry, should've known a fuel in a heavier hydrocarbon range was needed.
> Thanks for the correction and your patience, Warren.

Hey, that's what I am here for. Of course lighter fluid works great for getting
all the dustbunnies out of your keyboard. Just spay that puppy down real good,
wait about 2 minutes and fire it up. The dustbunnies soak the lighter fluid up
and burn off while leaving your keyboard clean and shiny - with a nice minty
smell too!

alienboy231

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 1:55:53 AM9/17/00
to
I'm lucky everyone in the world is not as useless as many of those who
visit this ng. I have made my backup of Thief 2 and although it took me
some time (mostly because of the pointless post in this ng) it works just
fine. And making a backup is not illegal just visit Gamecopyworld.com for
more information. And I find it slightly ironic that you guys consider this
stealing (which I again say it is not) and yet to play a game called Thief
in which you run around towns killing, knocking out, OH and STEALING. Oh
yeah and one last thing why the hell does Thief 2 run like fricking Deus Ex
on my computer. Hell Deus Ex even runs better and that game is way more
complex w/ 32 bit textures and all that. I have a Prophet 2 GTS 64 Meg.
But since those who have read these messages probably think I am a complete
a-hole I will go to gamefaqs and ask the question there too. Chow!

Your Buddy,
alienboy213

duckhater

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to
> But since those who have read these messages probably think I am a
complete
> a-hole I will go to gamefaqs and ask the question there too. Chow!
>
> Your Buddy,
> alienboy213

Not only are you eloquent, you are an educated man, alienboy. Chow is a
dog, buddy. Probably the reason most people doubt your intentions on using
this copy (founded or unfounded), is that piracy is getting pretty
widespread as you probably know. I've bought probably hundreds of games on
CD and never had one fail or needed a backup of one. I've never even heard
of anyone having a game fail on them in all the years I've been playing
computer games. So you can see our skepticism when you come asking for a
copy, especially when you say you have multiple programs for the exclusive
purpose of duping CD's (original post). Just remember everytime you dupe a
game to save yourself a few bucks you take some money out of the pool for
development of cutting-edge games for the future. You might not think one
person matters, or you might not even give a shit, but it adds up brother.
Have fun with your "backup"

Ciao,

duck


alienboy231

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to

Ciao I see. I piss people off thus making me a target and then I spell
one word wrong (oh god, if I spelled more wrong please don't let me know
because I truely DON'T CARE!) and I get poked fun at. Typical NG stuff.
But then again this was said "Not only are you eloquent, you are an educated
man" so Duckhater this message wasn't intended to storm conflict with you
but rather to make a point. Don't get me started with the gaming industry
not getting any from me. I had to have purchased hundreds of games in my
time. Some of my more recent purchases are:

Rugby 2001 (PC) EA Sports ***THIS GAME RULES!! If only Americans would give
rugby a chance. But of course you people have to watch basketball and
baseball, leaving me with the freakin European league on Fox Sports World
and the rare Ausie Rules league which is way better.
NFL2k1 (Dreamcast) Sega Sports ***How god damn this game is good if only
Dreamcast were to have a Rugby game made by Visual Concepts)
Diablo 2 (PC) Blizzard ***I now have no life or at least Im not living it
anymore I am now a Necromancer and my name is Creon
UFC (Dreamcast) Crave ***Best fighting game ever PERIOD.
Rush 2049 Midway/Atari ***Gran Turismo can suck my left nut sims suck arcade
racers rule.

Also you must be very good with your CDs not having any of them scratch and
not work because of that scratch. I on the other hand have problems with
this you see there is always a 2 year old gremlin running around my house
grabbing anything and everything that looks shiny or pretty and while I do
my best to keep her away from my computer she still manages to get to it
some of the time. Also there is a 6 year old child who likes to play my
games he seems to have problems putting them back in their cases and somehow
finds a way to scratch them. So I guess backing up my CDs is a bad idea
for my case. You people always assume the negative or the worse hell, if I
were to tell you there was a 3% chance of lightning to strike you on a rainy
day you all would probably take shelter in your god damn cellar.

Jez

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to
If you're having problems with CDs getting scratched and therefore
knackered, try using CDefender. I know its on sale here in the UK, so its
probably avaiable in the US. Its around £5 for 10 of them, and you stick
them to the bottom of the CDs, and they become nigh on impossible to
scratch. Pretty darn nifty if you ask me, and saves the trouble of copying
the CD.

Jez
"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

alienboy231 wrote in message ...

Jez

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to
Thief II is a GAME, copying the game is in REAL LIFE. Just thought I'd clear
up this problem for you :Ź)

Jez
"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

alienboy231 wrote in message ...

ManOwaR_freak

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to
On a dark day i sat in my room suddenly an
arrow flew thru the window into the ceiling
on it was a note and there was written :

why not using a buldozer to drive allover your computer with the cd inserted

"we are ManOwaR we are invinceble"
"death to false metal"
Warren <war...@onlineoptions.net> schreef in berichtnieuws


39C3F5D8...@onlineoptions.net...
> duckhater wrote:
>
> > Sorry if some others in the group seem a little self-righteous to you,
> > alienboy, so I'll tell you how to make a copy of the CD just to show you
> > we're not all mean-hearted. Use 2 drives - put the blank one in your
> > CD-writer. Take your original Thief CD, and clean it with lighter
fluid.
> > Throw a match on it, insert it in your drive, and run your duping
software.
> > Voila! There you go. Glad I could help.
>
> NO NO NO!!! How many times do we have to post this?? It's NOT lighter
fluid,
> its Gasoline!! Lighter fluid will ruin your CD - too much alkaline.
>
> You need to soak it in gasoline with an octane of 89 or higher for 3.5
minutes,
> THEN place it on the 2nd CD tray, light it, and close the door.
>
> Try to keep up, duck.
>

ManOwaR_freak

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to
On a dark day i sat in my room suddenly an
arrow flew thru the window into the ceiling
on it was a note and there was written :

i have one game that fails installing just because of one scratch on the cd


"we are ManOwaR we are invinceble"
"death to false metal"

duckhater <rove...@pacbell.net> schreef in berichtnieuws
Wn_w5.580$UV1.2...@news.pacbell.net...


> > But since those who have read these messages probably think I am a
> complete
> > a-hole I will go to gamefaqs and ask the question there too. Chow!
> >
> > Your Buddy,
> > alienboy213
>

duckhater

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/17/00
to

"SpammersDie" <Spamm...@blah.com> wrote in message
news:lXex5.3172$Cq6.2...@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net...

> > And I find it slightly ironic that you guys consider this
> > stealing (which I again say it is not) and yet to play a game called
Thief
> > in which you run around towns killing, knocking out, OH and STEALING.
>
> Oh puhleaze - I enjoyed Tie Fighter too - does that make me an advocate of
> big government?
>
This is a sweet post. During the hundreds of time I saw Star Wars, I never
once thought of the empire as one huge bureaucracy under a soverign leader.

SpammersDie

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 10:17:53 PM9/17/00
to
> And I find it slightly ironic that you guys consider this
> stealing (which I again say it is not) and yet to play a game called Thief
> in which you run around towns killing, knocking out, OH and STEALING.

Oh puhleaze - I enjoyed Tie Fighter too - does that make me an advocate of
big government?

SpammersDie

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 10:19:39 PM9/17/00
to
> You people always assume the negative or the worse hell, if I
> were to tell you there was a 3% chance of lightning to strike you on a
rainy
> day you all would probably take shelter in your god damn cellar.

Hardly. Running to the cellar every time it rains would be unproductive.

On the other hand, we lose absolutely nothing by pissing you off.


SpammersDie

unread,
Sep 17, 2000, 10:22:52 PM9/17/00
to

alienboy231 <alien...@home.com> wrote in message
news:J1Zw5.3076$Y6.4...@news1.mntp1.il.home.com...

> I'm lucky everyone in the world is not as useless as many of those
who
> visit this ng.

On the contrary - many people who speak out against piracy are precisely
those who are useful; useful enough that someone's willing to part with
their hard-earned dollars for the privilege of using the software they
create.

They're not useless; they just don't feel like expending energy to make
_your_ life easier.


Der Dok

unread,
Sep 21, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/21/00
to
I guess blowing up an entire frigging planet to test their new space toy
doesn't count as an evil act.

Zach wrote:

> > This is a sweet post. During the hundreds of time I saw Star Wars, I
> never
> > once thought of the empire as one huge bureaucracy under a soverign
> leader.
>

> One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies - what
> did the Empire do wrong? You never actually saw them do anything evil, you
> just heard them talk about the Dark Side. The only big thing that Darth and
> friends did was blow up a rebel military base, which you really can't hold
> against them. Just why were the Rebels rebelling?


Zach

unread,
Sep 22, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/22/00
to
> were to tell you there was a 3% chance of lightning to strike you on a
rainy
> day you all would probably take shelter in your god damn cellar.

First of all, to correct your earlier post, CD-Copying IS illegal. In any
form. Check a law book for more details, but the gist of it is that you can
only copy the files to a hard drive from the CD without permission from the
manufacturer.

Secondly, if there was a 3% chance of lighting to strike me on a rainy day,
that would mean that I have a one in 33 chance of death. Hell, that's a
good chance, not something I'd want to trifle with. How often do you go out
in the rain? 10, maybe 20 times a year. If there were a 3% chance of
dying, I'd probably live less than 2 years. (Yes, I know my math isn't
perfect, I don't feel like working out the exact probabilty) Considering
the chances of actually dying of a lighting strike are something closer to
100 million to one, though, it's really not that much of a risk.

Zach

unread,
Sep 22, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/22/00
to

Soulbringer

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to
Didn't you guys ever copy music onto a tape? That's just as illegal. And we all
do it.

Zach wrote:First of all, to correct your earlier post, CD-Copying IS illegal.

SpammersDie

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to

Zach <z...@g.com> wrote in message news:8qh6hr$9qs$1...@bob.news.rcn.net...

> > This is a sweet post. During the hundreds of time I saw Star Wars, I
> never
> > once thought of the empire as one huge bureaucracy under a soverign
> leader.
>
> One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies -
what
> did the Empire do wrong?

Their disposition of Alderaan was certainly lacking in due process, wouldn't
you say?

Also, aboard the Executor, their method of employee discipline would
probably violate a few labor regulations here on Earth.

duckhater

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to

>
> Their disposition of Alderaan was certainly lacking in due process,
wouldn't
> you say?
>
> Also, aboard the Executor, their method of employee discipline would
> probably violate a few labor regulations here on Earth.
>

I agree. Bob Knight is a saint when you compare him to Vader. I mean, the
dark lord choked way more people - with out touching them, even.

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to
On Fri, 22 Sep 2000 23:01:46 -0400, "Zach" <z...@g.com> wrote:

>> This is a sweet post. During the hundreds of time I saw Star Wars, I
>never
>> once thought of the empire as one huge bureaucracy under a soverign
>leader.
>
>One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies - what

>did the Empire do wrong? You never actually saw them do anything evil, you
>just heard them talk about the Dark Side. The only big thing that Darth and
>friends did was blow up a rebel military base, which you really can't hold
>against them. Just why were the Rebels rebelling?
>

You are not serious are you??? How about genocide(blowing up Alderran) and
torture(Han, Leia, and Chewbacca) for starters.


Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

Zach

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to

"Soulbringer" <fi...@hotsteak.com> wrote in message
news:39CDDB6F...@hotsteak.com...

> Didn't you guys ever copy music onto a tape? That's just as illegal. And
we all
> do it.

All criminals try to justify it to themselves by pretending everyone is as
bad as them. Not everybody is. And note that there are legal ways to copy
music onto tape.

Zach

unread,
Sep 24, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/24/00
to
> >One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies -
what
> >did the Empire do wrong? You never actually saw them do anything evil,
you
> >just heard them talk about the Dark Side. The only big thing that Darth
and
> >friends did was blow up a rebel military base, which you really can't
hold
> >against them. Just why were the Rebels rebelling?
> >
>
> You are not serious are you??? How about genocide(blowing up Alderran) and
> torture(Han, Leia, and Chewbacca) for starters.

Killing rebels. An act of war. And torture really depends on how you look
at it - it could save lives.

Morgan Sales

unread,
Sep 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/25/00
to
"Zach" <z...@g.com> wrote in message news:8qh6d6$8pm$1...@bob.news.rcn.net...

> > were to tell you there was a 3% chance of lightning to strike you on a
> rainy
> > day you all would probably take shelter in your god damn cellar.
>
> First of all, to correct your earlier post, CD-Copying IS illegal. In any
> form. Check a law book for more details, but the gist of it is that you
can
> only copy the files to a hard drive from the CD without permission from
the
> manufacturer.

Depends on the individual copyright agreement, I can't find one for thief or
thief 2 but I've got the manual for Jedi Knight here and it superficially
says that you can create *one* copy for backup purposes only.

Hold on just found the licence agreement on the thief2 CD, and yep, you're
right, it says : "you will not make any further copies in any way
whatsoever" either way, I take a somewhat unstringent view to copyright
laws, it's also illegal to lend out your games, or keep things taped of the
TV for longer than X amount of time. I wouldn't refrain from making a
personal backup if I felt the need. And in the case of Origin (just to get
off the point) I'll happily copy any of there games, basically because I
paid out good money for Ultima 9 and have now been inform that the latest
version id bug free and no further patches will be released. That's a
blatant lie even on the UK release.

--
Morgan.
----
* If money truly is the root of all evil I must be eligible for sainthood by
now.

Mail: Msa...@tesco.net
Webpage: http://homepage.ntlworld.com/msales


Jez

unread,
Sep 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/25/00
to
Technically, the rebels were rebelling against a legally established
government, this could be considered evil and probably justifies SOME of the
things the Empire did, but not Alderran.

Jez
"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

Scott Aguirre wrote in message <39ce9454...@news.earthlink.net>...


>On Fri, 22 Sep 2000 23:01:46 -0400, "Zach" <z...@g.com> wrote:
>
>>> This is a sweet post. During the hundreds of time I saw Star Wars, I
>>never
>>> once thought of the empire as one huge bureaucracy under a soverign
>>leader.
>>

>>One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies -
what
>>did the Empire do wrong? You never actually saw them do anything evil,
you
>>just heard them talk about the Dark Side. The only big thing that Darth
and
>>friends did was blow up a rebel military base, which you really can't hold
>>against them. Just why were the Rebels rebelling?
>>
>
>You are not serious are you??? How about genocide(blowing up Alderran) and
>torture(Han, Leia, and Chewbacca) for starters.
>
>

>Scott Aguirre
>slag...@earthlink.net

Soulbringer

unread,
Sep 25, 2000, 10:47:51 PM9/25/00
to
>All criminals try to justify it to themselves by pretending everyone is as
>bad as them.

So you are saying that people who make mixed tapes are criminals?


>Not everybody is.
You're right. But not everybody who responded negatively to the original
poster is without guilt
when it comes to some type of illegal (but unenforced) copying of various forms
of media: VCR,
audio tapes etc., and I'm willing to bet at least some of these hypocrites have
participated in some of
the more riskier activites such as downloading mp3s of commercial music, and
then perhaps burning
the music to a cd.

I'm not calling everyone hypocrites, but I believe there are a few that speak
out against software piracy, yet
are guilty of the same crime under different circumstances. I'm in NO WAY
condoning software piracy either.

Kevin Goodsell

unread,
Sep 26, 2000, 12:02:04 AM9/26/00
to
I claim that the difference between digital and analog makes those two
different issues. Tapes sound worse, and get progressively worse from
generation to generation, therefore they are not likely to cause anywhere
near the kind of harm that warez causes. Besides that, record companies can
afford to take that loss much more than most game companies can. The demise
of Looking Glass Studios is evidence of that.

So, a more reasonable analogy would be making CD copies of commercial
records. I've never done that, won't allow it to be done using my burner,
and generally explain to people who do it that it is wrong.

-Kevin

Soulbringer wrote in message <39D038CF...@hotfish.com>...

Morgan

unread,
Sep 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/26/00
to
"Zach" <z...@g.com> wrote in message news:8qm89a$clg$1...@bob.news.rcn.net...

> > >One thing about Star Wars - given the information only in the movies -
> what
> > >did the Empire do wrong? You never actually saw them do anything evil,
> you
> > >just heard them talk about the Dark Side. The only big thing that
Darth
> and
> > >friends did was blow up a rebel military base, which you really can't
> hold
> > >against them. Just why were the Rebels rebelling?
> > >
> >
> > You are not serious are you??? How about genocide(blowing up Alderran)
and
> > torture(Han, Leia, and Chewbacca) for starters.
>
> Killing rebels. An act of war. And torture really depends on how you
look
> at it - it could save lives.
>
>
I have to agree there...our own country has no qualms about torturing
operatives from other countries...they just make sure it doesn't go public.

--

Morgan

My new favorite line from LEXX: "Bitch-slap her, Xev!"

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 26, 2000, 9:29:42 PM9/26/00
to
On Mon, 25 Sep 2000 20:06:53 +0100, "Jez" <jez.t...@virgin.net> wrote:

>Technically, the rebels were rebelling against a legally established
>government, this could be considered evil and probably justifies SOME of the
>things the Empire did, but not Alderran.
>
>Jez
>"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared himself
Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 26, 2000, 9:33:13 PM9/26/00
to
On Tue, 26 Sep 2000 18:55:47 -0400, "Morgan" <kf4ytrNEG...@crosswinds.net>
wrote:

Whether our country does it or not, torture is WRONG. Remember also that Vader's
torture of Leia, Han, and Chewie was NOT to gain any critical info that would
save lives("Thet never even asked me any questions!"). It was all part of a plot
to lure someone else there to be kidnapped(but I guess if torture is OK, then
kidnapping is not so bad<friendly sarcasm>).


Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

Mel C

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 2:03:39 AM9/27/00
to
"Scott Aguirre" <slag...@earthlink.net> wrote

> On Mon, 25 Sep 2000 20:06:53 +0100, "Jez" <jez.t...@virgin.net>
wrote:
>
> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared
himself
> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.

"given the information only in the movies" was one of the the premisses
of this 'debate', and I ceratainly don't remember any of that! Or maybe
I wasn't paying attention during them... :-)

Attentive Spice


Zach

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/27/00
to
> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared himself
> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
> Scott Aguirre
> slag...@earthlink.net

But we didn't know that from watching the movies.

Zach

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/27/00
to
> Whether our country does it or not, torture is WRONG. Remember also that
Vader's
> torture of Leia, Han, and Chewie was NOT to gain any critical info that
would
> save lives("Thet never even asked me any questions!"). It was all part of
a plot
> to lure someone else there to be kidnapped(but I guess if torture is OK,
then
> kidnapping is not so bad<friendly sarcasm>).

Really depends on the perspective. Which would you prefer - someone to
suffer for a relatively short time, or someone to be dead? If you torture
them, they get kind of beat up and unhappy. If you kill them, they're gone.
If the Empire considered Luke an enemy, it was acceptable, albeit a little
unneeded. The thing is, Luke conceivably could have killed a lot of
innocent people.

Speaking of killing innocent people, what about blowing up the Death Star?
Yes, there were soldiers, but if their military is anything like ours, it
was filled with civilian employees. And the second Death Star was filled
with construction crews. Even excluding the fact that most of the Storm
Troopers had families and kids, there were probably thousands of innocent
civilians on board who had no idea what was going on. Yes, wars kill
people, but you'd think they could have come up with a better way than
nuking the entire station.

Jez

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/27/00
to
Exactly, I was going on the information from the movies, not the more recent
books, as good as they are :Ź)

Jez
"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

Zach wrote in message <8qt3ia$cv4$1...@bob.news.rcn.net>...


>> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared
himself
>> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
>> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
>> Scott Aguirre
>> slag...@earthlink.net
>

Jez

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM9/27/00
to
Think the count is 1million people on the Death Star, so probably a lot of
families a mite pissed off.

Jez
"Bolt cutters on stand-by"

Zach wrote in message <8qt3pv$e13$1...@bob.news.rcn.net>...

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 11:00:44 PM9/27/00
to

Sorry to say that you were not paying attention. :-) In the first movie(Episode
IV), Grand Moff Tarkin comes in and interrupts the meeting of the other Moffs.
Vader is following him in. He says something to the effect that the Senate will
no longer be a problem because Palpatine has disbanded the Senate, thereby
"wiping away the last remnants of the Old Republic." Something like that. Sorry
I can't quote verbatim. Also, Obi-Wan tells Luke that Vader helped the Emporer
hunt down and kill the Jedi Knights. Believe me, before I sent that post, I sat
and thought awhile to make sure what I was saying was in the movies. :-)


Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 11:01:11 PM9/27/00
to
On Wed, 27 Sep 2000 11:24:17 -0400, "Zach" <z...@g.com> wrote:

>> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared himself
>> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
>> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
>> Scott Aguirre
>> slag...@earthlink.net
>

>But we didn't know that from watching the movies.
>

Yes we did. See my other post. :-)

Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

Scott Aguirre

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 11:02:19 PM9/27/00
to
On Wed, 27 Sep 2000 18:35:43 +0100, "Jez" <jez.t...@virgin.net> wrote:

>Exactly, I was going on the information from the movies, not the more recent

>books, as good as they are :¬)


>
>Jez
>"Bolt cutters on stand-by"
>

>Zach wrote in message <8qt3ia$cv4$1...@bob.news.rcn.net>...

>>> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared
>himself
>>> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
>>> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
>>> Scott Aguirre
>>> slag...@earthlink.net
>>

>>But we didn't know that from watching the movies.
>>

Hey, I have only read one of the books, "DarkSaber" because I like to stick to
canon. :-)

Scott Aguirre
slag...@earthlink.net

SpammersDie

unread,
Sep 27, 2000, 11:37:14 PM9/27/00
to

Scott Aguirre <slag...@earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:39d2b32a...@news.earthlink.net...

> On Wed, 27 Sep 2000 07:03:39 +0100, "Mel C" <spe...@btinternet.com>
wrote:
>
> >"Scott Aguirre" <slag...@earthlink.net> wrote
> >> On Mon, 25 Sep 2000 20:06:53 +0100, "Jez" <jez.t...@virgin.net>
> >wrote:
> >>
> >> What legally? Palpatine disbanded the Republic Senate and declared
> >himself
> >> Emporer. Is that a legally established government. As part of his
> >> coup(spelling?) he had the Jedi Knights hunted down and killed.
> >
> > "given the information only in the movies" was one of the the premisses
> >of this 'debate', and I ceratainly don't remember any of that! Or maybe
> >I wasn't paying attention during them... :-)
> >
> > Attentive Spice
> >
>
> Sorry to say that you were not paying attention. :-) In the first
movie(Episode
> IV), Grand Moff Tarkin comes in and interrupts the meeting of the other
Moffs.
> Vader is following him in. He says something to the effect that the Senate
will
> no longer be a problem because Palpatine has disbanded the Senate, thereby
> "wiping away the last remnants of the Old Republic." Something like that.
Sorry
> I can't quote verbatim.

However, for all we know, he had the legal power to do this. We can certain
agree the Empire wasn't a democracy but that doesn't mean it's not legally
established either. Going by the information in the movies, we have no
evidence yet that Palpatine wasn't legally elected to power (though he
certainly used some questionable means to gain a platform.)

> Also, Obi-Wan tells Luke that Vader helped the Emporer
> hunt down and kill the Jedi Knights. Believe me, before I sent that post,
I sat
> and thought awhile to make sure what I was saying was in the movies. :-)

But we only have Obi-Wan's word about the Jedicide. And we know how
trustworthy *that* is!


0 new messages